In a recent decision (CAA Versailles, July 8, 2015, n°13VE01079), the Versailles Administrative Court of Appeals (CAA) provided an interesting illustration of the operation of the specific anti-abuse provision (i.e., different from the general abuse of law theory) attached to the dividend withholding tax exemption provided, in accordance with the EU Parent-Subsidiary Directive, by Article 119 bis of the French tax code (FTC). Following an audit performed in 2010, the FTA challenged the withholding tax exemption applied by a French company (FrenchCo) in respect of the dividends it distributed in 2007 to its sole shareholder, a company located in Luxembourg (LuxCo). All of the shares of LuxCo but one were held by a company located in Cyprus (CypCo), itself held by a company located in Switzerland (SwissCo). Under Article 119 bis of the FTC, the standard 25 percent withholding tax applicable to dividends is eliminated, provided inter alia that the recipient of the dividends is not part of a holding structure that is constitutive of an artificial arrangement whose main purposes is the benefit of the withholding tax exemption. After confirming that such specific anti-abuse provision complies with EU law freedoms to the extent that it aims at combating tax evasion, the CAA took the position that the burden of the proof attached to the purpose of the holding structure was on FrenchCo (in principle, the burden of the proof falls on the recipient of the dividends, but only where the recipient is a party to the litigation, which was not the case for LuxCo; however, under general French...
Dividend Withholding Tax Exemption And Specific Anti-Abuse Provision
|Author:||Mr Siamak Mostafavi, Nicolas André and Alexios Theologitis|
To continue readingREQUEST YOUR TRIAL
- Mondaq France
- Arbitration In France: The 2011 Reform
- New Arbitration Law In France: The Decree Of January 13, 2011
- French Court Supports Freedom Of Authentication: A Win For Art Experts
- Does French Law Recognise A Duty To Mitigate?
- French Tax Update - Noteworthy Tax Courts Decisions And Draft Macron Law
- French Supreme Administrative Court Decision Significantly Broadens Scope Of The French Sunshine Act
- Toward Class Actions For Health-Related Claims In France
- French Tax Update - Recent Noteworthy French Tax Court Decisions
- Debt-Push-Down Challenged Under Abuse Of Law Theory
- Dividend Withholding Tax Exemption And Specific Anti-Abuse Provision
- Advocate General Opines In ECJ Case Targeting Dividend Withholding Tax
- Macron Law Modifies French Insolvency Law
- French Tax Update - French Finance Bills
- French Tax Update - Recent Case Law And Other Noteworthy Publications
- Legal Revolution In France Civil Law Reforms (Or Napoleon's Second Coming)
- French Data Protection Wants To Force Google To Extend The Right To Be Delisted To All The Search Engine's Extensions
- Article In Bloomberg BNA: The Right To Be Forgotten Protection Or Hegemony?
- Entering Into Force On 1 July 2016, The French Draft Law On Health Class Actions' Will Bring With It More Complexity And Legal Uncertainty
- Mediate Or Lose Your Claim. A Salutary Reminder For Claimants In French Court And Arbitration Proceedings
- Foreign Discovery Under 28 US Code Section 1782 In French Proceedings
- A Tale Of Dirty Deals, Demurrage And Discontent: Enforcement Of Arbitral Award Refused
- Pre-Contractual Negotiations A New Codified French Regime
- Wildenstein Art Dynasty Heirs Acquitted Of Tax Fraud
- Again The Life Science Industry Will Have To Take A Close Look At A New Set Of Regulations Reshaping Transparency-Related Obligations
- Paris Court Of Appeal Potentially Increases Scope Of The Doctrine Of 'Adverse Inferences'
- Consortium De Réalisation Prevails In Final Chapter In Tapie Dispute
- Third-Party Funding The French Perspective
- Who Wins, Where And Why? Paris, France
- The International Chamber Of The Paris Court Of Appeal Will Become Operational On March 1st, 2018
- The International Chambers Of The Paris Courts And Their Innovative Rules Of Procedure
- Renewed Interest In French Class Actions?
- About The Importance Of Implementing The BDES (Economic And Social Data Base)!
- Violation Of The 'Anti-Kickback' Statute: The French Supreme Court Upholds The 2017 Decision Of The Paris Court Of Appeal Imposing Record Fines
- Preventing The Enforcement Of A First Demand Guarantee Within A Few Weeks' Time: Story Of A Successful Case
- The National Assembly Proposes Picking Bercy's Lock
- Conditions Governing The Admissibility Of A Motion To Dismiss Based On Estoppel
- Gaillard's Chaos Theory
- Return Of Artworks To Africa: A Legal Conundrum
- The Launch Of The Prague Rules: Useful Or Unnecessary Tool For International Arbitration?
- Article 145 Of The French Civil Procedure Code Constitutes An Effective Weapon, Provided You Know How To Wield It
- Investment Arbitration Under The Energy Charter Treaty
- 2018-2022 French Programming Act For Justice: Inching Towards Virtual Justice?
- Les 7 articles les plus consultés et partagés sur le site August Debouzy
- Anxiety From Asbestos Exposure: French Compensation Model Extended To Other Toxic Substances
- WIPO Becomes First Non-Chinese Entity To Administer .CN Domain Name Disputes
- Astrid Mignon Colombet Joins August Debouzy As Partner
- Expanding Involvement Of Courts In Arbitration Makes Sense
- Proving Corruption In Investment Arbitration Lao Holdings v. The Lao People's Democratic Republic
- Secrecy Of Pre-Trial Investigations And Inquiries: A Fundamental Principal Undermined By Social Changes