Maximum Administrative Fine Issued By The CNIL Against Google: More To Come?

Author:Mr Daniel Kadar
Profession:Reed Smith
 
FREE EXCERPT

After almost two years of back and forth with Google, the French CNIL has, similarly to the Spanish Data Protection authority (€900,000 fine), sanctioned Google with a €150,000 fine, as Google refused to review its integrated platform and to modify its privacy policy as requested by the Working Party 29.

In addition to this fine, the CNIL has ordered Google to post a warning on Google's French home page within eight days after the CNIL's notification, and during two days reflecting this condemnation.

Google has decided to appeal the CNIL's condemnation in front of the French Council of State ("Conseil d'Etat"), France's highest administrative jurisdiction, in order to obtain the cancellation or reversal of the decision.

One could wonder why Google puts so much energy into trying to reverse a condemnation that is "bearable" from a financial point of view: there are at least two reasons for this.

First, the warning to be posted being the "real" condemnation - as it is deemed to be displayed to millions of Google users - Google has no other choice but to appeal the decision in order to avoid it. And as the appeal does not hinder the immediate enforceability of the sanction, Google had simultaneously introduced a petition for suspension before the Conseil d'Etat.

The hearing is scheduled to take place February 6, 2014.

Second, and more importantly, this condemnation could be the first step before criminal penalties this time: the French criminal...

To continue reading

REQUEST YOUR TRIAL